← All essays

    Excerpted from 55 and Out, Personal Finance

    The Insurance Audit That Saved $3,200/Year

    ·3 min read

    I had four insurance policies on autopay: home, auto (two cars), and an umbrella. Annual premiums totaled around $9,400. They had drifted up about 6% a year for the last decade with no changes to the underlying risk. I'd been ignoring it.

    Here's what an afternoon found.

    Step 1: get all four declarations pages in one folder. Took ten minutes via the insurer's portal. I read each one carefully — coverage limits, deductibles, replacement vs. actual cash value, named exclusions, "miscellaneous" line items.

    Step 2: get three quotes. Used an independent broker for two of them and a direct online tool for the third. Same coverage limits, same deductibles, same liability levels. The quotes came back over a few days.

    Step 3: call my current insurer with the lowest competing quote. Polite, factual: "I have a written quote for the same coverage at $X. Can you match or come close?" My current insurer dropped my premium by about 14% in five minutes. They didn't even ask for the competing quote document.

    Step 4: switch the ones where the savings were big enough to matter. I moved the home and umbrella to a new carrier, kept the auto where it was at the negotiated price.

    Net savings: about $3,200 a year. Same coverage. Same deductibles. Same agent for the policies I kept.

    What I learned about deductibles: most people are over-insured at the low end. I bumped the home deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 and the auto deductibles from $500 to $1,000. Saved about $400/yr in premiums on top of the renegotiation. The trade is real — if I have a claim, I'm out an extra $1,500–$2,000. But over a decade with no claims, I'm $4,000 ahead.

    What I learned about umbrella coverage: it's wildly cheap relative to what it covers. My umbrella went from $1M to $2M of coverage and the premium went up by $87/yr. Net of the home savings, this still came out ahead.

    What surprised me: how quickly the original insurer dropped the price when I asked. They had been pricing my inertia, not my risk. The lesson — call them every two years, even if you're happy. Inertia is a tax you pay until you stop paying it.

    What I'd do again: this audit, every two years. What I wouldn't: let an "insurance review" turn into an excuse to upsell new policies. The agent will try. Politely decline. The audit is about the policies you have, not the policies they want you to have.

    Share

    This essay is excerpted from the book.