Excerpted from 55 and Out, Simplification
Two Credit Cards. That's It.
I'm a recovering points-and-miles person. At my peak I had eleven cards, a spreadsheet of bonus categories, and a calendar of which card to use at which merchant in which quarter. The "value" I was extracting was real — maybe $1,500 a year in net rewards after fees.
It was costing me more than that in attention.
I closed nine cards. I kept two:
- A no-fee 2% cash-back card for everything that isn't travel.
- A travel card with a fee that I justify because I travel enough that the perks (lounge access, no foreign transaction fees, decent points) actually pay for themselves.
That's it. No quarterly bonus tracking. No "what category am I paying in?" lookup. No spreadsheet. No 5/24 rule worry. Tax time is two statements instead of eleven.
What I gave up: about $1,500/yr in optimized rewards. The new setup gets me roughly $700/yr in rewards. Net cost of the simplification: about $800/yr.
What I gained: the time I spent managing the points game. Conservatively two hours a month, often more — researching the next welcome bonus, executing the spend, tracking the categories, managing the credits. Twenty-four hours a year, valued conservatively, was worth more than the $800 I gave up. Not even close.
What surprised me: how much mental load was attached to those cards. Each one came with credits to use, deadlines to meet, fees to evaluate annually. The relief at not having to think about any of it was bigger than the financial cost.
What broke: my credit score dipped about 12 points temporarily from closing the cards. It recovered within four months. Not enough of a difference to matter for anything I do.
What I'd do again: simplify earlier. What I wouldn't: close every card on the same day. Stagger the closures over a few months to avoid the bigger score dip and to keep one or two open accounts as a backstop while the dust settles.
The deeper lesson: optimization is its own tax. You can spend the rest of your life squeezing 2% extra out of every category of life, and at the end you'll have eked out a few thousand extra dollars at the cost of years of attention. The trade isn't worth it. Do the simple version. Get on with your life.