← All essays

    Excerpted from 55 and Out, Personal Finance

    When I Sold a Business: What I Wish I'd Known About Taxes

    ·3 min read

    I sold a small business several years ago. The headline number was good. The take-home was less good than I expected, by an amount large enough to hurt. Here's what I wish I'd known.

    One: the tax bill is set by the structure long before the sale. By the time you're at the closing table, the structure of the entity, the basis you've built up, the years of K-1 history, the asset vs. stock decision — all of that is already done. The window for tax planning around a sale is years before the sale, not weeks before. If you think you might sell in three to five years, talk to a tax attorney now, not when the LOI arrives.

    Two: an asset sale and a stock sale are very different things, and the buyer cares. The buyer almost always wants an asset sale (better tax treatment for them, less liability inherited). The seller almost always wants a stock sale (better tax treatment, cleaner exit). The negotiation around this can be worth a lot of money. I gave away more than I should have because I didn't fully understand it going in.

    Three: state taxes can dwarf federal taxes in a sale year. If you live in a high-tax state, the state takes a serious bite. Some states tax the sale as ordinary income at the state level even when it's capital gains federally. Some have one-time addback rules. I learned this two months before the close, when it was too late to do anything about it. Know it years in advance.

    Four: the buyer's earnout terms are tax events, not just cash flow events. An earnout that pays out over three years can be taxed in interesting ways depending on how it's structured. "Same money, taxed differently" is real. The lawyer who structures the earnout should be in conversation with the tax person who knows your situation.

    Five: the year of the sale is the year for charitable timing. If you're going to give significantly during your life, the year of a large taxable event is the year that giving has the most tax leverage. A donor-advised fund opened in the sale year, funded with appreciated stock, can convert a tax bill into a giving plan. I did this. It was the single best financial decision I made that year, and it almost didn't happen because I was focused on the closing and not on the calendar.

    What I'd do again: hire the tax attorney earlier. What I wouldn't: assume my regular CPA, who is excellent at annual returns, is also the right person for transaction tax planning. They are usually different people. Pay the specialist.

    The deeper lesson: the difference between a good outcome and a great outcome on a once-in-a-lifetime transaction is almost entirely planning that happens long before the transaction. If something big is on your horizon, the work to do this year is the planning, not the transaction itself.

    Share

    This essay is excerpted from the book.