← All essays

    Excerpted from 55 and Out, Personal Finance

    Why I Hold Boring Index Funds and Sleep Through the News

    ·3 min read

    I started with the funds in 2014. They are still the same funds today. I have not added a fifth. I have not "tactically tilted." I have not chased any sector. I have not sold during any of the three serious drawdowns I've lived through with this portfolio.

    The funds:

    1. Total US stock market index
    2. Total international stock market index
    3. Total US bond market index
    4. A small slice of REITs

    The split has barely moved over a decade. Rebalanced quarterly back to the target. That's the whole strategy.

    The performance: roughly market returns minus a tiny fraction for expense ratios. The expense ratios on the funds I hold total about 0.06%. That's six basis points. Six dollars per ten thousand per year. The advisor I used to pay charged 100 basis points. The same portfolio at his price would have cost me roughly 94 basis points more per year, every year, forever.

    What I do during a market crash: read a paper book, take a walk, look at the rebalance column in the spreadsheet, buy a little more of whatever is most underweight, go back to the book.

    What I do during a market boom: the same thing. Look at the rebalance column, sell a little of whatever is overweight, buy a little of whatever is underweight, go back to the book.

    What I don't do: read financial news. Watch CNBC. Open Robinhood. Look up "what's a good stock to buy in 2026." Those activities have no positive expected return for me. They generate trades, and trades generate fees and taxes, and fees and taxes are the friction that erodes the boring strategy.

    What surprised me: how hard it is for some people to believe this is the whole strategy. They keep waiting for the punchline. The punchline is the absence of a punchline. Boring stuff, repeated for decades, with low fees, beats almost everyone who tries to be clever.

    What broke: my conviction once, in 2020, when I almost moved a chunk to cash. I called my brother instead of acting. He said "it'll be fine. it's always fine if you wait." The next two weeks were the worst of the drawdown. The next two months were the best months the market had had in a decade. I would have missed it. The brother is now my designated panic-button human.

    What I'd do again: all of it. What I wouldn't: try to time anything, ever. I'm not smart enough. Most people aren't, including the ones who get paid to try.

    Share

    This essay is excerpted from the book.